Clefsight Allow keyboard

How Clefsight works

How your playing is graded, how your reading profile decides what comes next, and what a keyboard can't tell us.

How we grade

Your own beat
We grade your timing against your own beat, not the metronome. Play slower or faster than the marked tempo and, as long as you keep it steady, every note can still be on time. If your tempo drifts, we follow it; that shows up in Steadiness, not as late or early notes. Your beat is read from the notes that fall on the beat, so a rhythm played wrong every time (a dotted rhythm played even, a long note cut short) shows as those notes early or late, not as a new tempo. With the metronome on, its click helps settle which beat you meant. A take ends when you stop playing after its last note, or press Stop, however slowly you play.
The numbers
After a take you get one mark out of 100, and under Details the four it is made of, each out of 100 too. Notes and Rhythm count notes: Notes the written notes you played with the right key, Rhythm the notes you played with the right key that were on time, and the result says how many of how many. Keep going and Steadiness aren't counts of anything: Keep going starts at 100 and loses points for each break, Steadiness says how even your beat stayed. A dash (–) means the take gave nothing to measure, such as no two notes in a row to time: it isn't a zero, and it leaves that part out of the mark. In Wait the mark is the percentage of notes right, and wrong keys, stops and hints are counts.
The pencil marks
After a take the page comes back marked in two colours, as a teacher marks a copy. Red circles a wrong or missed note, and beside a wrong one writes the key you played. An early or late note is drawn in blue, with a faint blue outline of it nudged back (to the left) for early and on (to the right) for late. The further off the note was, the further its outline sits, from about a third of a staff space just past on time to a whole space at a beat or more. While you play, the timing help ticks them instead: a blue tick before a note, leaning back (\), early; after it, leaning forward (/), late. A red + over a bar counts extra keys that went in there (+2 for two). The bars that need the most work (up to three, each under 80 % of its notes' credit: a right key counts in full, less for its moment early or late, three quarters under a quarter of a beat off, half under half a beat, a quarter beyond, a chord once; an extra key takes half a note off) are bracketed, with their number over the bracket's corner ("bar 12"): in red where keys went wrong, missed or extra or you stopped, in blue where every key was right and only the timing was off. A right hand or left hand played an octave off all through is said once, over its first note, not circled note by note. A grey line marks where a take stopped or skipped bars, and nothing after it is marked. Where you went back, "went back" is written in grey over the bar you went back to; the keys you played again there aren't extra. Right notes get no mark.
The advice
Under the mark, one line says what to try next. When one thing runs through a whole hand (it played an octave off, most of its notes weren't played, or it came in just after the other hand on the notes written together), the line names that before any bar; otherwise it names the bracketed bars and what went most wrong there.
Notes
Each written note you played with the right key counts. A wrong key in the right place is a wrong note; a note you didn't play is missed; a note that isn't in the music is extra, and counts as half a wrong note. A wrong key played when a note was due is that note played wrong, even when it is the next note's key: it counts as the next note played early only when your timing says so. A wrong key put right at once (a key up to a tone from the note, then the note within half a beat) costs the extra key once: the note counts on time if the wrong key was.
Rhythm
A note is on time within a tenth of your beat (at 80 beats a minute, 75 ms either way), and never tighter than 30 ms, or 45 ms on a Bluetooth keyboard, whose timing wobbles more. Outside that it is early or late; up to twice that earns half credit. One late note doesn't make the next one early: if you hesitate and carry on, only the hesitation counts. Your first note starts the clock, so it is always on time.
Chords
Notes of a chord count as played together when each follows the one before within about 60 ms (a little more on a Bluetooth keyboard), so a rolled or slightly spread chord is one chord, on time if its first note is. A chord marked to be rolled may spread more than twice as wide.
Ornaments and pauses
Play a trill, mordent, turn or grace note the way you learned it: its quick notes never count as extra, and a long appoggiatura (one small note without a slash) may take the beat, its main note after it, on time if the small note was. At a pause (a fermata), hold as long as you like: it isn't a stop, and we start following your beat afresh after it. Where the music slows down (rit., rall. or allarg., up to the a tempo, and the end of a piece, its last bar and the half bar before), a note that comes later as you slow isn't marked late.
Keep going
The first rule of sight-reading is to keep going. Each stop (a gap at least twice what the music asks and over a second longer than it), each restart and each skip, however many bars it jumps, takes 10 points off. Stopping before the end takes off the share of the notes left unplayed, and never less than 10 points. If you go back, we grade the last time you played each bar, and going back again before you've played on two notes counts as the same go-back. Phrase by phrase, a short phrase that falls short (under three quarters of its notes, a note early or late counting for part of one and an extra key taking half a note off), or that you're more than a beat late in, goes back to its first note and is played again, at most twice: the take is graded on the last time you played it, and its mark counts each phrase's best go, the first in full, a first replay at most 80 and a second at most 60. On a phrase's last go the metronome waits for you instead: each wait is a stop, the playing either side of it is timed as one stretch, and the phrase counts as fallen short. Straight through never stops or replays: you play on to the end. Fresh sight-reading is played once: stop partway and Notes counts only the notes you reached, your reading level moves by the part you played, then the next piece comes.
Steadiness
How much your beat changes from bar to bar, and from the start of a stretch of playing to its end. Changes up to 2 % a bar and 5 % overall are free, so a slow, steady speeding up costs a little too. It is a score out of 100: a beat that held is 100, and it reaches 0 at a change of 20 % a bar, or a drift of 50 % from start to end. A note already marked early or late isn't counted again here: a hesitation you carry on from costs Rhythm, not Steadiness too. It needs two bars played without a break; before that it shows a dash.
The click
With the metronome on, we also measure how far you end up from its click. It isn't part of any mark, since your timing is graded to your own beat, but from half a beat behind or ahead the advice says so, and where: the click is what you were asked to keep with.
Wait mode
In Wait, the music waits for you: it holds at the next note or chord until you play it, with no clock. Play a chord's notes together, or hold each one down until the last arrives. Wrong keys don't move you on; we count each as half a wrong note. Take it at whatever pace you like: holding one place at least twice as long as your own pace asks, and over a second longer, counts as a stop, and after 4 seconds at one place you can ask for the note names, which we count too. If you stop partway, the share right is of the notes you reached, and we say where you stopped; the step is passed only by playing to the end.
Rhythm only
When you practise the rhythm alone, any key will do: only when you play counts. It's graded like a normal take: Rhythm, Keep going and Steadiness, as above. Keys pressed together count as one chord.
Lengths and pedal
Only when the music asks for them, and they count for little: a note should sound for at least 60 % of its written length (the pedal counts), and marked pedal should be down for most of its span, and come up where the music marks a change, within half a beat of it, so one harmony doesn't blur into the next.
Overall
A mix of the marks above, led by Notes and Rhythm, and never higher than your Notes mark: music you skipped or played wrong can't hide behind good timing. Each break also lowers the most it can be by 10, to no less than 50: one stop, and the mark is 90 at most, so stopping always costs more than a hesitation you play through, and a take with a break is never called clean.
Your setup
The tap-along calibration measures your keyboard's delay and how much it wobbles. The delay is taken off every note, and a wobbly setup gets wider windows, so your keyboard's delay doesn't cost you marks.
What we can't check
Fingering, hand position, posture, tone and the balance between your hands can't be read from a keyboard's signal, so we don't grade them. Loudness depends on each keyboard, so it is only ever compared with your own playing.

How your profile works

One profile
Everything you play, in drills, fresh sight-reading and your pieces, feeds one picture of what you read: every line and space in each clef, key signatures, sharps and flats, intervals and chords, rhythms and playing with both hands. For each one we keep how often you get it right, how fast you find it, and how well you remember it after time away.
Right first, then quick
Something is introduced when you play it right three times, however long you take: the next one opens then. It is remembered once you get it right again after a break, and fluent when it is right, quick and remembered. Quick means under a second for a single note, a little longer for a key signature, an interval or a chord, and half as long again on the keys on screen or the letters, which take longer to find than a keyboard's. Reading it right in a fresh piece at your sight-reading tempo, or faster, counts as quick too, because you read it inside the beat. A little over the time is not a wall: a note you find in just over a second is remembered about as soon as one you find in just under, and the slower you are the more often it comes back. The goal is to know it without thinking, which frees your eyes to read ahead. Rhythms and hand coordination have no clock: playing them on time is the test.
One hand position at a time
You learn in the order a teacher would use, starting from middle C. New notes come a hand position at a time, the five notes under the right hand first, each brought in on its own before they mix. When one is introduced, the next one opens. The warm-up runs for its minutes, with what is due to come back first. Rhythms and hand coordination have their own next step, so they move along with your reading.
Coming back at the right time
Something you just met comes back tomorrow, then in a few days, then in a week or more, each time you remember it. Get it wrong and it comes back in a few minutes, then starts its spacing again. Many right answers in one sitting count about as much as one: what matters is remembering after a break, so your progress, the course's topics and what counts toward a piece being ready wait until you have remembered it.
Your pieces count too
A note that goes wrong in a piece turns up in your next warm-up, and we tell you where it was, what you played for it and, when only one reading explains it, why: a sharp or flat forgotten, the other clef, an octave off, or the next line or space. Outside fresh sight-reading, right and wrong notes both count half as much as in a drill, because fingers that know a piece can play it without reading, so one rough play can't undo what you read well: the rougher a play is all through, the less its wrong notes count, and one that goes badly leaves what you read without thinking as it was, for the next warm-up to check. One wrong note among a few moves what we know of that note only a little; it takes a second slip on it to make it fade. Music you never reached, after you stopped or in bars you skipped, says nothing about your reading; only the take's grade shows it. Nor does a right note struck inside a handful of other keys: it was found, not read, so it counts in the grade and nowhere else.
Your reading level
Only the first time you play music you have never seen moves your reading level. That is the honest test of reading, so the fresh pieces we write for you are the ones that count. Your level is where your first plays come out at about 85; a clean first play moves it up, a hard one moves it down. Stop partway and it counts for the part you played, as far as you got: a few clean bars move it up a little. Speed and difficulty move one at a time: at each level, fresh pieces start slow and a clean first play makes the next one a little faster instead of harder; once you read clean at the level's full speed, clean plays move your level, and the next level starts slow again. A rough one slows the next piece a step. Each fresh piece's own level is measured from its notes, the way the library's pieces are, and a first play is weighed against that, so your level never climbs past the hardest fresh piece you have played clean by more than half a level. Music well under your level, played well, never lowers it; only a rough first play of it does. Until three fresh pieces in a row near your level agree with it, it reads as a whole number, settling.
Ready, a stretch, not yet
A piece is ready when about nine tenths of its notes use things you already read without thinking, and a stretch from three quarters. A note you remember but don't yet read quickly counts from half up to nearly all of it, the nearer your time is to quick, so a reader always a little over the time still finds pieces to play; one you read well until a recent slip counts half, so one wrong answer doesn't close a piece. We list what's new in it and drill those first.
The level test
On your first visit, Today asks whether you read music already. If you do, a test finds where you are, so you don't start at middle C. It keeps asking until it is sure: each card's answer changes how likely each topic is, and the next card is the one that tells it most. A miss never decides alone (anyone slips), so a topic is asked again; once a topic is clearly out of reach, so is everything built on it, and it stops asking there. The treble and bass staffs are read apart, and rhythm apart from notes. A right answer counts however long it takes, up to a limit (4 seconds for a note); the time sets your pace, which the result shows. It usually takes a few minutes and stops by itself. After that, what it credited fades like anything else you read: a wrong answer or a rough play lowers it a step at a time, never back to the start.
Learning a piece
A piece you are learning goes in steps, the way a teacher would set them: the right hand alone, then the left, then both hands, all in Wait, where the music waits for you; then phrase by phrase: the clicks keep the beat, and a phrase that trips you up, or that you're more than a beat late in, goes back to its first note and comes round again, up to twice; on its last go the clicks wait for you instead, and go on from the note you play, in time with you. A clean take moves you on to Steady, where the metronome never stops and nothing comes round again: you keep going whatever happens. A step in Wait passes the first time 90 % of the notes are right and you didn't need the note names. A take like that with both hands passes the hands-alone steps too, and a piece written for one hand skips the other hand's step and Both hands. With the metronome, the first take is a little slower than the pace you kept with both hands in Wait, and each clean take (85 overall, 90 for notes and 75 for rhythm, with at most one stop, restart or skip, at nine tenths of the asked tempo or faster) makes the next one 5 % of the marked tempo faster, through 60 % and 80 % to all of it. A rough take keeps the tempo; two in a row take it a step slower. The − and + beside the tempo move it yourself. Every Steady take is played on a bare page, nothing marked as you go, and marked after. Once you play it clean at the marked tempo you can take it faster, up to a quarter more, for the fun of it; that never moves your reading level.
Help on the page
Nothing on the page moves ahead of you, so your eyes are free to read on. While you keep time the page stays still; once you're 15 % of a beat late for the next note it gets a faint pencil mark, red from 50 %, and a note you rush gets a small blue tick before it, as on the marked page. Early notes still count as played. In Wait the music simply waits for you. Choose Off under Options for a bare page; your choice holds for every piece until you change it.
Loops
When the same bar is among your worst on two takes in a row, we offer to loop it. A loop starts a little slower than the piece's tempo and gets faster by 5 % of the marked tempo each time you play it cleanly, up to the piece's tempo; a clean time through at that tempo finishes it.
Your repertoire
Each piece you have learned keeps a fluency mark: how well your plays with both hands and the metronome went lately, less for playing slower than marked, fading the longer you leave it. A piece you once played well that fades below 70 comes back as one to play again. Playing it after a few days away keeps it longer than many plays in one day.

What you need

A MIDI keyboard (most digital pianos and keyboards have a USB port) and Chrome or Edge on a computer or an Android phone or tablet, or Firefox on a computer. Safari, iPhone and iPad can't connect a keyboard to a web page. Without a keyboard, you play on keys on screen: pieces, fresh sight-reading, the drills, the level test and the games. A MIDI keyboard is closest to reading at the piano, and a two-hand piece wider than the screen moves its keys along as you play.

Choosing between apps? How Clefsight compares with Simply Piano, flowkey, Skoove, Playground Sessions, Piano Marvel, MuseFlow, SightReader, Sight Reading Factory and Synthesia for learning to read, and when one of them is the better choice.

What Clefsight is for

The library goes up to level 7, about Henle grade 7: advanced pieces such as Chopin's Fantaisie-impromptu. Beyond that, what matters most (voicing, pedalling, phrasing, rubato) is what a keyboard's signal says least about, so Clefsight is for learning to read and play, not for polishing a recital.

The library is public-domain music only: pieces old enough to be free in both the United States and Canada, and traditional tunes. Modern songs, pop and film music aren't in it; you can bring your own score as MusicXML or a MIDI file.

Your data

Your reading profile, practice, takes and scores live in your browser, on this device. Nothing about your playing is sent to us unless you sign in, when a copy is kept on your account so it follows you to any computer (privacy). Settings can save a copy to move to another browser. To count how many people use Clefsight, the browser sends a random number, made once and kept in the browser, at most once a day, when a keyboard connects.

Learning with someone? Send them this page by email